ponytails chincoteague sweets superstore

Online Store is now OPEN and taking orders!

Pony Tails Candy Company was founded in 1965 as Chincoteague’s only candy superstore. For more than 50 years, we have been providing visitors and locals of Chincoteague Island fresh saltwater taffy, creamery fudge, handmade chocolates, Dolle’s caramel popcorn and a full line of gummies, licorice and novelty candies.

Pony Tails is also the Island’s premier destination for gifts, home décor, toys and jewelry. We pride ourselves on being family friendly – there is something for everyone, for every budget at Pony Tails!

Still family owned and operated since 1965, we hope you enjoy your visit to our store on “the Island” and on the Internet.


  • We are currently closed for renovations.
  • However, online orders are still being processed! Please shop via our online store.
  • We will be closed from January 11th through February 29th, and will return to the store in early March

Hours are highly dependent on business needs and may change without notice.