Pony Tails Candy Company was founded in 1965 as Chincoteague’s first candy store. For over 46 years, we have been providing visitors and locals of Chincoteague Island fresh salt water taffy, homemade creamery fudge, delicious chocolates, as well as a full line of gummies, licorice, and novelty candies.
Pony Tails also offers a full line of souvenirs, gifts, beach apparel, and children's toys. We pride ourselves in being family friendly -- there is something for everyone, for every budget at Pony Tails!
Still family owned and operated since 1965, we hope you enjoy your visit to our store, on “The Island”, or on the internet!